In partnership with
Reading time: 6 minutes | Follow me on LinkedIn / Sponsor this newsletter
Greetings from above,
Why did the customer break up with the coffee shop?
He was tired of the daily grind and wanted more perks.
Seriously though, I was talking with a client last month who runs a fantastic online store. Great products, solid traffic.
The problem? Her customers had the loyalty of a stray cat. They'd buy once, then vanish forever.
She was stuck on the "customer acquisition treadmill," constantly spending more on ads to replace the customers she couldn't keep.
We used this exact proposal framework to map out a simple loyalty program. It wasn't about just giving away discounts. It was about making her customers feel like insiders. Within two months, her repeat purchase rate had climbed by 40%.
Today, we'll talk about:
How to stop paying to re-acquire the same customers.
The psychological triggers that create true brand loyalty.
A complete blueprint for a loyalty program that actually makes you money.
Let's dive in!
Marketing ideas for marketers who hate boring
The best marketing ideas come from marketers who live it.
That’s what this newsletter delivers.
The Marketing Millennials is a look inside what’s working right now for other marketers. No theory. No fluff. Just real insights and ideas you can actually use—from marketers who’ve been there, done that, and are sharing the playbook.
Every newsletter is written by Daniel Murray, a marketer obsessed with what goes into great marketing. Expect fresh takes, hot topics, and the kind of stuff you’ll want to steal for your next campaign.
Because marketing shouldn’t feel like guesswork. And you shouldn’t have to dig for the good stuff.
💬 THIS WEEK'S READER QUESTION
"My business gets a decent number of first-time buyers, but almost none of them ever come back. It feels like I'm running a business of one-night stands. How do I build a real relationship and get them to stick around?"
This is the sound of a business with no moat. In a world with endless options, a good product isn't enough. If you're not giving your customers a compelling reason to return, you're just a transaction. And transactions are forgotten. Loyalty isn't an accident; it's a system.
🎯 What The Prompt Does
This prompt stops you from guessing what might make customers loyal and forces you to build a professional, data-driven loyalty program proposal. It's a strategic document that outlines the entire system, from the psychology of your customers to the financial return on investment.
It solves the problem of "transactional relationships" by giving you a blueprint to create a community and reward repeat behavior.
🔥 How The Prompt Works
Think of this prompt as an expert consultant that specializes in customer retention. It walks you through every critical section of a professional business proposal. It forces you to analyze your industry, understand your customers' motivations, design a compelling rewards structure, and even project the financial impact.
Key benefits:
Professionalism: Generates a document you can use to get buy-in from your team or investors.
Clarity: Provides a step-by-step implementation roadmap.
Profitability: Includes financial projections to prove the ROI of your program.
⚙️ Loyalty Program Architect Prompt ⚙️
What it does:
This prompt generates a comprehensive and persuasive business proposal for a customer loyalty rewards program, tailored to any industry. It covers everything from the high-level strategy and industry analysis to the nitty-gritty details of the rewards catalog, gamification elements, and implementation timeline.
Why this matters:
Saves Thousands on Consultants: Creates a professional-grade strategic document in minutes.
Turns Customers into Fans: Designs a program that makes customers feel valued, not just marketed to.
Justifies the Investment: The financial projections section clearly shows how the program will pay for itself and drive growth.
Here’s the full prompt:
#CONTEXT:
Adopt the role of an expert business proposal writer specializing in crafting compelling loyalty incentive programs across various industries. Your task is to help the user create a comprehensive, persuasive proposal for implementing a customer loyalty rewards program in their specified industry.
#ROLE:
You are an expert business proposal writer specializing in crafting compelling loyalty incentive programs across various industries.
#RESPONSE GUIDELINES:
The proposal should include the following sections:
Executive Summary:
Provide a concise overview of the proposed loyalty program, highlighting its core objectives and potential impact on customer retention and revenue growth.
Industry Analysis:
- Industry Characteristics: Briefly describe key aspects of the industry, such as competition level, customer preferences, and market trends.
- Customer Insights: Discuss relevant customer behaviors, motivations, and pain points that the loyalty program aims to address.
Loyalty Program Framework:
- Program Structure: Outline the tiered rewards system, including criteria for earning points/rewards and redemption options.
- Enrollment Process: Explain how customers can sign up for the program and any initial incentives for joining.
- Rewards Catalog: Provide examples of appealing rewards tailored to the industry and customer preferences.
- Gamification Elements: Describe any game-like features that encourage engagement and repeat purchases.
- Personalization Strategies: Discuss how the program will leverage customer data to deliver targeted offers and experiences.
Implementation Roadmap:
1. Phase 1 Milestone: Key actions and timeline
2. Phase 2 Milestone: Key actions and timeline
3. Phase 3 Milestone: Key actions and timeline
4. Phase 4 Milestone: Key actions and timeline
Financial Projections:
Provide a table outlining the expected costs, revenue impact, and ROI of the loyalty program over a specified timeframe.
Conclusion:
Summarize the key benefits of implementing the proposed loyalty program and its potential to drive long-term customer loyalty and business growth in the industry.
#TASK CRITERIA:
1. The proposal should be well-structured, coherent, and effective in conveying key points and benefits.
2. Utilize dependency grammar framework to ensure clarity and persuasiveness.
3. Provide specific, actionable recommendations tailored to the industry's unique characteristics and customer base.
4. Focus on the potential impact on customer retention and revenue growth.
5. Avoid generalities and ensure all insights and recommendations are supported by industry and customer analysis.
#INFORMATION ABOUT ME:
- My industry: [SPECIFY THE INDUSTRY]
#RESPONSE FORMAT:
The proposal should be formatted as follows:
- Use headings and subheadings to clearly delineate each section
- Use bullet points for lists and key insights
- Include a table for financial projections
- Use paragraphs for the executive summary and conclusion
Perfect for:
Retail & E-commerce Stores: Looking to increase repeat purchase rates.
Cafes & Restaurants: Wanting to turn casual visitors into daily regulars.
SaaS Companies: Aiming to reduce churn and increase customer lifetime value.
Implementation tip: When you fill in the [My industry] variable, be as specific as possible. "High-end women's fashion boutique" will get you a much better proposal than just "retail."
Use ChatGPT-5, Claude Opus 4.1, or Gemini 2.5 Pro for best results!
❓ HOW TO USE THIS PROMPT ❓
STEP 1: Enter your specific industry in the [INFORMATION ABOUT ME] section.
STEP 2: Run the prompt to generate the entire, multi-page business proposal.
STEP 3: Pay close attention to the "Rewards Catalog" and "Financial Projections" sections. Customize these with your actual product costs and business metrics to make the proposal truly your own.
📤 EXAMPLE OUTPUT 📤
♻️ PROMPT VARIATIONS ♻️
🎯 SaaS Retention Engine:
#CONTEXT:
...Your task is to create a proposal for a loyalty program for a B2B SaaS company focused on reducing monthly churn. The rewards should be tied to product usage, feature adoption, and providing feedback.
... (keep the rest of the structure)
📧 E-commerce VIP Club:
#CONTEXT:
...Your task is to create a proposal for an exclusive, tiered VIP loyalty program for a luxury e-commerce brand. Focus on non-discount rewards like early access to new collections, personal styling sessions, and exclusive content.
... (keep the rest of the structure)
🚀 Local Service Business Booster:
#CONTEXT:
...Your task is to create a proposal for a simple, easy-to-manage loyalty program for a local service business (e.g., hair salon, car wash). Focus on rewarding frequency and referrals.
... (keep the rest of the structure)
🏆 WEEKLY PROMPT CHALLENGE 🏆
This week, use the prompt to design a loyalty program for a business that doesn't typically have one.
#CONTEXT:
...Your task is to create a loyalty program proposal for a B2B accounting firm. How do you gamify doing your taxes? What does a tiered rewards system for financial services look like?
... (fill in your details)
Share your most creative ideas by replying to this email!
💡 PROMPT TIP OF THE WEEK: Gamification is Not a Gimmick
The "Gamification Elements" section is your secret weapon. People are wired to love progress and achievement. A simple points system is boring. A system with tiers, badges, and surprise rewards is addictive.
Before:
- Program Structure: Customers earn 1 point for every $1 spent. 100 points = $5 off.
After:
- Program Structure:
- Bronze Tier (0-100 pts): Earn 1 pt per $1.
- Silver Tier (101-500 pts): Earn 1.25 pts per $1, get early access to sales.
- Gold Tier (501+ pts): Earn 1.5 pts per $1, get a surprise birthday gift.
- Gamification Elements:
- Unlock the "Super Fan" badge after 5 purchases.
- A progress bar in the customer's account shows how close they are to the next tier.
The "After" version turns spending money into a game that customers want to win.
📋 SUMMARY 📋
This prompt creates a complete, professional business proposal for a customer loyalty program.
It forces you to think strategically about customer retention, not just acquisition.
It provides a clear implementation roadmap and proves the financial ROI of your program.
📚 FREE RESOURCES 📚
📦 WRAP UP 📦
What you learned today:
How to build a customer moat: A well-designed loyalty program gives customers a reason to stay.
The anatomy of a winning proposal: From industry analysis to financial projections, you now have the structure.
Why gamification works: Turning loyalty into a game increases engagement and repeat business.
What did you think about today's edition?
Stop renting customers through ads. It's time to own the relationship. This prompt is the blueprint.
And as always, thanks for being part of my lovely community,
Keep learning,
🔑 Alex from God of Prompt
P.S. What's the best loyalty program you've ever been a part of? Reply and let me know why it worked.
